Doing Time in Hanfeld Mills
When Will Wierzbicki wondered, as he often did, about the tangled heap of mistakes that made up his life, he wavered on whether to award first or second prize to his name. Regardless of where it placed in that race to the bottom, he assigned blame for it to his mother.
His half-brother, the product of her first marriage, sailed through life as David John Wright, for the boy’s father had put his foot down when she proposed eccentric baby names. David Wright went right to the top and made his living as an architect in the Pacific Northwest, designing sleek, glassed-in homes for the millionaires whose ranks he joined in record time.
But Will’s father was made of softer stuff, so his mother had her way, and while other children in the first grade learned to write their names in a day or two, Will struggled for weeks to trace the letters of Wenceslaus Willard Wierzbicki, the home-barbered line of red bangs drawing a severe line across his forehead, the tip of his tongue curled over his top lip in concentration, his sweaty knuckles white on his pencil as if he could squeeze the correct spelling from it.
Most nights and weekends, Will’s father escaped to his work shed, where he fashioned inlaid wooden boxes and cutting boards. He gave them away to friends and strangers alike; his payment came in the form of an excuse to be out of the house to do more woodworking. From an early age, Will tagged along, and his father would let the boy sort through his toolbox of odds and ends. They’d sit together in mote-speckled shafts of sunlight, Will making tidy piles of hex nuts, brads, and screws, his father working, their silence broken only by the zip of a hand planer or the whisper of sandpaper, the air free of complaints and criticisms.
Will proved all bloody thumbs and mangled palms in the work shed; and he counted not learning to work with his hands among the mistakes of his life. After his father died too young, Will kept the dented toolbox, the odds and ends inside become treasures, and running his fingers through them became a way of bringing back the days of quiet father-son camaraderie.
When the lone and harried guidance counselor of the high school pulled out her drawer of index cards filled with career choices, Will skipped right over those that involved power tools and pulled out those that made use of his rigorous logic and ability to perform calculations in his head but also respected his need for quiet. He closed his eyes, made a wish, and drew three cards. He shuffled the three, read them through slitted eyelids, and chose the one that came closest to mattering to him—loan officer at a bank.
The bank was where he met Vanessa, trim and bubbly, her clothing and words all business but flirtatiousness sparkling through the long lashes of her brown eyes. He approved of the sparkling eyes; he approved the loan for her business, too.
“You But Better.” Her honeyed voice poured out the words.
“What?” he asked, pulling the loan agreement back to his side of the desk.
She slid a business card to him, spun it his way.
“That’s okay,” he said, spinning it back. “I can read upside down.”
And he did, to prove it: “You But Better. Vanessa Jackson, Professional Organizer.”
“I had the cards printed in advance.”
Will scowled. “Why risk the expense of cards you can’t use?”
“Because I simply knew I’d get the loan.”
At their wedding reception, hanging onto Will’s elbow, Vanessa told that story at every table, adding that in addition to the loan, she had known she’d get the man, too.
She moved into his condo on the main street of Whitbury and set about organizing things. She weeded out Will’s green ties but left the plum and rust ones that would make his grey eyes look blue, transferred all the pantry staples to Mason jars with brush-lettered labels, and reshelved his books by spine color.
Vanessa and Will—mostly Vanessa—entertained guests with gourmet meals, clever cocktails, and perfect tablescapes. They sipped coffee on the patio together as they watched the sun set. They made love in every room. Will and Vanessa were very, very happy.
Until they slipped over an invisible tipping point into a place where they weren’t.
Will noted it first in her nostrils, a tiny flare of them when he came home from the bank each day, as if she’d caught a whiff of something unpleasant. Then he saw it in her lips, tight as if they’d been drawn up like a purse string, lips like his mother’s.
“How could I have married a man who smears garlic cream cheese on cinnamon-raisin toast?” she asked over breakfast one day, nose wrinkled like an adorable yet vaguely menacing rabbit. She added, “Just kidding.”
But she wasn’t. She tossed the garlic cream cheese as well as the cinnamon-raisin bread during a fridge clean-out, videos of which she posted on her website and social media feeds. The WTF- and OMG-emblazoned thumbnail of the components of Will’s beloved breakfast created the buzz Vanessa wanted for You But Better. Garlic cream cheese on cinnamon-raisin toast trended for seventy-two hours and elicited comments that, before long, devolved into battles over gender roles, freedom of speech, and the Second Amendment.
Will spent his days on tenterhooks, waiting for Vanessa to pounce on him for whatever new transgression he might commit. Soon, he began regular retreats to their storage shed, which was just big enough for him, the recycling bin, and the trash can. He took his father’s toolbox from the lone shelf and ran his fingers through the odds and ends, struggling to remember whether Vanessa preferred the saltshaker to the left or right of the pepper, struggling to give a damn anymore. Surely, granting a loan for You But Better had moved to the top three mistakes of Will’s life.
Vanessa got his condo, their social circle, and the better of the two cars in the divorce. He found a curious sense of relief that the cat had run away a few months earlier, because the two humans acted like animals when dividing their shared possessions. They argued most of all over the satin-smooth wooden bowl that Will’s father made years before and to which Vanessa had become attached.
“Mr. Boots, I’m glad you were spared all of that,” Will mused on the six-month anniversary of the divorce, a preternaturally beautiful late summer Saturday with a breeze that bore hints of autumn. He inserted his key into the ignition of the old clunker and headed out for he knew not where.
Whitbury was on the smaller side of small-to-middling, and it gave way quickly to farmland and forest-draped hills. The old clunker strained but maintained the speed limit on the uphill grades and coasted happily on the downhill ones. The foul taste of divorciversary was fading from the back of Will’s tongue, and he took deep breaths of clean air. He drove until he found a place to stop—one of those two-street, four-block towns whose economic driver had become obsolete, leaving too many empty storefronts, all the free parking that no one was around to use, a church with an enormous cemetery, and more dead people than living.
Plus, to Will’s surprise, a microbrewery with a busy taproom. He pulled into its lot and parked in the shade of a row of maples, reveling in the jingle-bell song of crickets and the sparkling stream that tumbled by. To the left of the taproom’s door was a five-foot, fiberglass statue of a pheasant. Its tail was truncated; its body, bottom-heavy and lumpy, seemed modeled after a pear. But its button eyes shone a friendly greeting. Will judged that, as roadside art went, the statue was top-notch, and he decided to interpret the pheasant’s dumpy shape as intending to represent the moment the bird readied itself for flight. He took a selfie with it, mimicking the quirky tilt of its green and red head, before swinging open the door of The Darting Pheasant.
A beer and a bump and a plate of soft pretzel nuggets proved an excellent remedy for his embittered heart. A second and third beer and another bump overtaxed his liver and his bladder, which he realized only after he’d left the bar, patted the fiberglass pheasant on its head, and walked a nearly straight line to his car.
The stream beckoned, and he unzipped his shorts. He stood on the bank, the soles of his worn loafers getting muddy, the grass tickling his calves, burnished bare by years of wearing dress socks, the rest of his legs bristling with red hair. He swayed from side to side, laughing as he sprayed wide, broken arcs into the water. A breeze lifted the thin shelf of lacquered hair from his crown.
Whoop-whoop. He heard a siren chirp behind him.
“Whoop-whoop!” he replied.
Whoop-whoop. “Sir, what are you doing?” a voice came.
“Whoop-whoop! Watering the fish,” he replied through the warm buzz that suffused his brain. “They’re sooooo thirsty!”
“I’m going to have to ask you to stop.”
He looked over his shoulder and scowled at the intruder. “Stop? Well, maybe you girls can stop midstream, but we can’t. That’s an incontroberbibble biological fact.”
Later, standing before the magistrate and covering himself in contrition and humility, Will acknowledged that calling a state trooper a girl was a grave, grave error, and so was asking her how staties managed to keep the straps of their Stetsons on the tippity-tip of their chins.
“Mr. Wierzbicki,” the magistrate concluded. “Public intoxication, public indecency, assaulting a law enforcement officer—”
Will cleared his throat and interrupted as meekly as possible, “Now that last one is a misunderstanding, Your Honor. I wanted to point out to the officer that, even before she arrived, I had decided I wasn’t fit to drive, and I kind of stood up a little from the patrol car seat as I started to say that.”
“But her hand was on your head, protecting it, and, in standing, you smashed her hand against the roof rail.”
Will assumed the hang-dog posture he perfected in the latter part of his eight years with Vanessa, one that telegraphed a submission he didn’t always feel. “And for which I’m very sorry, Your Honor. I hurt myself, too.” He rubbed his head and added, “Perhaps the court would count it in my favor that I had already concluded it wasn’t a good idea to drive in that condition.”
“Eight hours of community service a week for the next six months,” the magistrate ordered. “Report by the end of this week to Colonel Everett at the Hanfeld Mills parsonage.”

When searching for directions to the parsonage, Will discovered that Hanfeld Mills was the name of the place where he had committed his misdemeanors. The parsonage—too highbrow a name for the one-bedroom cottage—sat behind the Presbyterian church, the only church in town.
The church was a jewel box, small with elegant proportions. Its red bricks stood crisp against the green grass and mature trees that dotted the enormous cemetery that surrounded it. The wooden trim of the door and stained-glass windows shed no brittle curls of fading paint; it was fresh and bright. Will shook off the sensation that he had fallen back in time to the days when Hanfeld Mills was thriving and the church was new.
The tumble-down parsonage hid in its shadow. On the front stoop, an old man perched on a folding chair stubbly with frayed webbing, enjoying his lunch of Manischewitz and microwave mac and cheese, a gray tabby winding around his ankles.
The man sported a worn but clean souvenir ball cap with “World War II” emblazoned on the crown and “Everett” embroidered on the bill. Will observed him—the arms and face covered in liver spots and wrinkles, the nose reddened by broken capillaries, and ears sprouting tufts of white hair—and performed mathematical calculations. The man was old, but despite the lettering on the cap, not old enough to be a member of the Greatest Generation.
Will ventured, “Are you Colonel Everett?”
“I am for now,” the man replied. He held out a piece of macaroni to the cat, who licked it as well as the man’s fingers clean of neon-orange sauce before taking delicate nibbles of the pasta. The man wiped his hand on his plaid shirt and extended it for Will to shake. “Are you my new community service convict?”
Will’s mouth worked as he sought an answer.
“Convict!” the colonel said on a wheezing laugh. “Just kidding! Want some lunch?”
“I already ate, sir.”
“Don’t ‘sir’ me, son. Are you sure? I just went to the grocery in Whitbury, so there’s plenty of food, and the sacristy’s got enough wine from now ’til kingdom come.”
“Doesn’t it upset them when you drink their communion wine, Mister Everett?”
“Don’t ‘Mister Everett’, me neither, son. Church closed; minister left. There ain’t no they no more to upset.”
“Who owns the building …” Will made another attempt, “… Colonel?”
“County historical society. They bought it for a song and fixed it up so they could put it on their tour. I room in the parsonage in exchange for looking after the place and get an honorarium from the court to supervise you miscreants. You going to keep your nose clean from here on out?”
He put down the nearly empty cup of mac and cheese, and the cat swept it clean with her tongue.
“Come on,” the colonel said. “Let’s show you the ropes and introduce you to my friends.”
Will stooped to smooth his hand over the cat’s back. “What’s your cat’s name?”
“Cat. Let’s go. Time’s a-wasting.”
They walked the four acres of the cemetery, Cat scampering behind them, past plinths carved in high relief with statues of angels riding atop, obelisks in pearly gray and pink granite, and an imposing mausoleum, all testaments to the glory days of Hanfeld Mills. The colonel chatted with some of the departed, letting them know that Will would be working with him and Cat for a spell.
“How many graves are there?” Will asked.
“Couple thousand plus.”
As they walked, the colonel made looping detours to run his hands along the bark of the specimen trees that dotted the cemetery. He told Will their scientific and common names.
“This old centurion here’s my favorite,” he announced as they approached a regal white oak. “He was already a giant before the church was built.”
“My father lathed a white oak burl into a bowl when I was a boy.”
“Liked woodworking, did he?”
Will nodded.
The oldest part of the cemetery was enclosed by a fieldstone wall with a well-oiled gate. There sagged tired headstones with weathered edges and letters worn to shallow furrows or altogether lost to time. Scattered among them were limestone lambs, and the colonel stopped to pet a cluster of three and to speak tenderly to the departed children who rested below.
“How do you know their names?” Will asked. “I can’t read them.”
“I had a good teacher. He told me their names. When he started here you could still just about read them names and dates. There’s a registry in the church. It ain’t complete, though. Angeline, Clara, and Irwin don’t got their names in it, so someone needs to remember. Angeline, two months old; Clara, one year and four days; Irwin, two years, two months, fourteen days.”
Will committed their names and ages to memory and bent down to stroke the lambs, recoiling from the thought, unnatural to his century, of parents burying so many tiny children.
“Well.” The colonel clapped his hands and broke Will’s reverie. “We’re done visiting. Time to get to work. Let me see them hands.”
Will held them out. The colonel inspected them, turned them over, and frowned. “Soft. What do you do for a living?”
“Loan officer at the bank in Whitbury.”
The colonel grunted. “You’re going to need gloves. You know how to mow grass?”
“I guess. I used to.”
The colonel shook his head in despair. “But you can drive a car, right?”
Gloves on, ears plugged, hat shielding his thinning crown from the sun, Will spent three hours on a riding mower, following the grid the colonel laid out for him, and another two guiding the string trimmer around headstones—gently, he had been warned, as the older limestone markers were soft and easily damaged.
“It’ll be dark soon, Will,” the colonel said at six. “You owe me two more hours this week. Come back tomorrow. You’ve got more trimming and a couple of indoor tasks to check off the list.”
Will plunged in with one more sorry truth about his skills: “I’m not very handy.”
“It ain’t complicated stuff, son. Changing a washer in the men’s room faucet, replacing toilet paper and paper towels. Do good with that, and I’ll promote you to loading refills in the soap dispenser. Careful, though. You need an Acto knife for that. Don’t go hacking off an appendage and leaving blood everywhere.”
Will earned a gold star in bathroom refills, and the colonel soon entrusted him with other tasks—leaf blowing, dusting the ornate candlesticks on the altar, straightening dozens of tiny Veterans Day cemetery flags that had blown askew in a storm, and recaulking the window in the parsonage kitchen. Will’s only demerit came after he failed to stake out the cemetery well enough on Mischief Night. Halloween’s dawn revealed that the bottom quarter of the cemetery’s majestic copper beech had undergone a thorough and exuberant TP-ing. Will spent many damp and chilly hours in November plucking soggy wads of toilet paper from the beech’s smooth, silvery trunk and ponderous branches and the muddy ground below it.
Christmas saw the colonel, Will, and Cat at a card table in the parsonage sharing a meal of Manischewitz, mac and cheese, and a store-bought roast chicken in the glow of faux candles they had borrowed from the sanctuary. As usual, they talked about the weather, Cat, and the work to be done around the church and cemetery, and they avoided politics and religion. Their private lives stayed private.
“Where do the salt and pepper go?” asked Will, standing to clear the table.
“Anywhere that’s not the fridge.”
“You sure?”
“Sure as shooting.”
The colonel wanted to commemorate their holiday together with a photo. He posed in front of the gate of the old cemetery, a plaid scarf wound around his neck, his coat buttoned, and his cap on. Cat lazed on the sun-warmed top of the stone wall, and Will stretched his arm out to take the picture.
“Can you get that snapshot out of the phone and onto paper?” the colonel asked.
“Onto paper and into a frame, too,” Will promised.
In April, Will completed his community service, but he asked the colonel’s permission to stay on. He had ideas for increasing visitor traffic to the church and cemetery and, with the historical society’s approval, wrote a grant proposal for a digital LED sign, a computer, a printer, and internet access. He wrote clever sayings for the sign and changed them weekly. He created a map of unusual headstones and of notable people buried in the cemetery and devised a scavenger hunt for children. He created a database of the cemetery’s residents and began the tedious task of populating it. He and the colonel gave tours of the property. Will volunteered to lead the outdoor segments of the tours, because the colonel was grousing about achy joints and the approach of The Reaper.
Despite those complaints, the old man’s death took Will by surprise that summer, and the fact that no one thought to inform him until almost a week later compounded his sorrow.
He called the historical society.
“Oh, yes, so sad!” said the volunteer who answered the phone.
Will protested, “But we were going to label all the trees in the cemetery so people knew what they were.”
“Poor old man! You know, hardly anyone came to the funeral.”
“I would have if anyone had bothered to let me know,” Will countered.
“That is so sweet of you!” Rather than apology or sorrow, the volunteer’s voice conveyed pleasure at the tasty gossip she had to share. “You know, he had only one relative who came, a niece or first cousin once removed or something. Our volunteer coordinator attended, of course, and the pastor from before the church closed. We only put out a half-dozen folding chairs, but even that was too many. Heartbreaking!”
Will hung up and channeled his churning emotions to a good purpose—he bought a bouquet of flowers and a brand-new American flag. In the sacristy, he scanned the pages of the cemetery’s registry for Colonel Everett’s resting place, but it had not yet been entered. Will drafted a Plan B—he walked the four acres in search of disturbed earth. Granite headstones winked at him in the late afternoon sun. Near the imposing white oak, he spied fresh squares of sod. Cat stood guard at the headstone and meowed a greeting.
“Is this the place, Cat?”
Will was dumbfounded; he stood before the headstone of Raymond Arlington Fenstermacher, born 1940, predeceased by wife, Eleanor, some thirty years before, veteran of no war. He turned to take in the sea of statues, obelisks, and headstones, wondering how his Plan B had failed. He started back to the church, calling for Cat. She remained behind, meowing insistently.
He paged through the cemetery registry for anyone with a first or last name of Everett. There were six for him to track down; at the third grave he found what he sought. To be thorough, he visited all six before circling back to the third, whose gray granite marker read:
Richard Montgomery Everett
Col
US Army
World War II
Oct 30 1920
Dec 1 1982
Bronze Star
Purple Heart
“1982?” Will asked, struck by the same sensation he had experienced his first day at the church, one of slipping through a crack in time. But if nothing else, he was certain of this much: He had not fallen into the past; it was the same 21st century day and year it had been when he rolled out of bed.
Will returned to the grave near the white oak. Cat remained on guard. Hoping he was in the right spot, Will placed the bouquet before the headstone and inserted the flag’s wooden dowel into the ground.
The next morning, he called the historical society to confirm the identity of the caretaker of Hanfeld Mills’ church and cemetery, but the volunteer who answered the phone protested that she was too new to answer his question
Will deduced that the magistrate’s office, who paid an honorarium for supervision of community service at the cemetery, must know more.
“Raymond A. Fenstermacher, yes,” the magistrate’s paralegal told him over the phone.
“Why did he call himself Colonel Everett?”
The paralegal chuckled. “We don’t really know, but he insisted. He said there’s always been a Colonel Everett out there. Judge Lehrer said we should humor him. What harm could it do?”
When Will hung up, he made the surprisingly easy decision to leave the bank behind. He applied for the vacancy at the Hanfeld Mills church and cemetery.
Vanessa called as he was driving to his new home.
“I heard you’re moving. And that you quit your job at the bank.”
“News travels fast in Whitbury.”
“You quit the bank to go and work in a cemetery like a ghoul or something? Are you out of your mind?”
“Not in the least.”
“Well, if you’re downsizing, could I have that wooden bowl your dad made?”
Will hung up on her.
She texted him: You are the biggest mistake I ever made in my whole life.
He dictated a reply: And you are the most consequential one in mine.
He parked next to the parsonage and carried his few boxes inside. Before unpacking a thing, he went to the front stoop, whistled, jangled the can opener loud and long, and cut the lid from a can of Cat’s favorite food. He was rewarded by the sight of her running toward him. She wolfed down the chicken-and-liver meal, walked indoors, and hopped onto the sofa to groom herself.
“Who’s a good kitty?” Will crooned. “Who’s the best roommate around?”
The colonel’s cap hung on a hook by the front door. Will took it in his hands and smiled in fond remembrance of the man who had been his mentor in Hanfeld Mills. But he shook his head in wonder at why he had called himself by another name.
On the bedside table Will discovered a cluster of photos taken at the gate of the old cemetery. In the first, Will and Cat posed on a sunny Christmas afternoon with Ray Fenstermacher in his Colonel Everett cap. In another photo, a younger Ray stood arm and arm with an old, stocky man whose blond hair was nearly hidden by the same cap. In the next, the blond was younger and leaner and laughed with a Black man who wore the cap instead. Will picked up the final, faded photo and made out the same man, this time sporting an enviably symmetrical afro, bell bottoms, and a fatigue jacket, his arm tossed over the shoulder of a bearded man who had just opened a gift—the cap that now dangled from Will’s left thumb.
Will snapped to attention to salute the original Colonel Everett and all the men who had filled his shoes through the decades.

The doorbell rang as Will was uploading botanical and common names of the cemetery’s trees to the new horticultural database, a plate of cinnamon-raisin toast with garlic cream cheese by the keyboard and Cat purring on his lap. He snugged on his cap and opened the door.
A gangly, abashed teenager ground the toe of his sneaker into the stoop. “Are you Colonel Everett?” he asked.
Janice E. Rodríguez grew up in the Philadelphia area with her nose in a book. When it was time to choose a career, she stayed true to her first love—books—and became a teacher of Spanish language and literature. When Janice isn’t reading or writing, you’ll find her in the kitchen working her way through a so-tall-it-wobbles stack of cookbooks or in the garden hollering at marauding squirrels. “Doing Time in Hanfeld Mills” is inspired by trips through small towns in Pennsylvania and her husband’s inexplicable choice of breakfast foods. Online: janiceerodriguez.com.